YouWriteOn   The free website to help new writers to develop, and to help talented writers get noticed and published.   Books
   
Welsh, Not (3) << Return To Main Site

YouWriteOn Message Board > The YouWriteOn Forum > NEW - YouWriteOn Members Recommend
Please read the Rules before posting Help Search Recent Posts
Welsh, Not (3)
Page 1 Start New Topic Reply To Topic
Reco
 23 Sep 2008, 01:17 #44552 Reply To Post
Title : Welsh, Not (3)

Author : Chris Pitt

Genre : Novel, General Fiction

Review Extract from Review By: KatM

"Free Will Review

Wow. This is fantastic writing. The voice of the main character is so strong and the relationships between them both beautifully drawn and very moving. I come from a working class Welsh background myself, with a very similiar (so far anyway) father and mother figure and I felt such a strong connection with your MC that it has quite shaken me up! Really powerful writing and a very well deserved place at the top of the list. Well done. I have no idea where it's going, but don't care. Would just love to keep going there with it. I would like to offer you some constructive criticism but find I can't think of anything to say except 'brilliant boyo'.

Good luck with this. It so derserves to be published.

Synopsis
Siôn, son of an extreme nationalist, born with the wrong coloured hair, reflects on his troubled life. But is it too late to change?
Enter any story title into the search function on the top right hand corner of the site to read the opening chapters.
Clairann
 23 Sep 2008, 15:45 #44611 Reply To Post
I totally agree - I reviewed this a few weeks ago and it keeps popping into my head ever since. I can imagine it as a film or a TV drama series actually, a sort of Ken Loach type production. Is there a Welsh Ken Loach out there? Maybe Chris can enlighten me! Anyway, excellent stuff.
'A person is a fool to become a writer. His only compensation is absolute freedom.' Roald Dahl
astormont
 23 Sep 2008, 21:26 #44638 Reply To Post
Yes I agree too. I could only come up with 2 measly typos by way of 'criticism'. It's a first class piece of writing and it stays with you. It'll be published I'm sure.
orpheus
 02 Oct 2008, 21:30 #45309 Reply To Post
Hey guys, check this out.

"it was a really wonderful read. I strongly urge you to upload a much larger portion next time.

I loved your writing style. You are indeed a superb writer. You have great talent, without a shadow of doubt. There’s something rather grandfatherly or grandmotherly or patriarchal /matriarchal about your flourishes, witticism, irony, the lot. Personally I adored it all.

Some of your description in its simplicity was stunning. I am not overstating that! For example:
“There were many skulls bleached a ghostly white, housing schools of little silvery fish that swam in and out of where the eyes and mouths used to be.”
I found this outstanding. Others may disagree. I don’t care. For me this is totally brilliant description which, in it’s cute slick simplicity creates a most fabulous and imaginative image.

I thought your humour was terrific too. Made me giggle my socks off! You have a bold and super sense of humor in your writing. Rococo would rather have been a dragonfly than a crocodile, for example. Lovely!

I found it rather adult actually. I found it almost “Jonathan Livingstone Seagull”-esque. Thus, I was racking my brains in working out what age level kids this work would be appropriate for. On the one hand, it is a simple story with almost picture book images. Yes, it would truly make a gorgeous picture book. On the other hand, the humour is surreal, sophisticated, and for whom. The kids would probably not get the half. That can be good, because many times parents read for kids - and even Hollywood tries to make kids’ movies that adults can enjoy when they accompany their kids. I personally adored the jokes and ironies but I am sure the kids would miss a lot."

I've just uploaded a couple of chapters and it's getting great reviews!
click here to read. Mummy Moo Crazy Claws & Rococo
Page 1 Add To My Topic Watch List Start New Topic Reply To Topic
Server Time: 04 December 2008, 20:50

Powered by Zarr Forums

5 Database Read(s) - 0.219 seconds


Adverts provided by Google and not endorsed by YouWriteOn.com.